Everts Family
Growing up, my cousin Ellen Everts lived upstairs from us with my paternal grandmother. We kids were always told to be extra nice to her and not to bother her and to be quiet around her. This always struck us as odd because she seemed like any other adult in the house in most regards. She was a court stenographer and practiced her shorthand at night by recording the dialogue on tv shows. She said the pacing was almost perfect. Ellen giggled like a little girl when I kissed her on the cheek goodbye, smoked Salems incessantly, and practiced yoga (where? Who in the 60’s had even heard of yoga?) but otherwise seemed just like all the rest of the adults in the house. My sister hated having Ellen as her middle name. Her father was Charles Everts who married Julia Ann Baumhauser. Remember her from 03-FEB? They operated a farm about 10 miles outside of Hot Springs AR. She had two sisters. Miriam Ollie was born in 1905. Thelma Lenora was born in 1913. Ellen was born in 1911. It was a prosperous farm. Charles’ sister Cornelia lived nearby. She had a son, Harry Lewter. Harry had been a cook in WWI for the 12th Calvary before returning home to work as a laborer on the railroad. He had a daughter, Mary Alice, in 1931 and married his 14 year old bride, Lena, a few months later. Fourteen is not a typo. At some point Ellen moved to Texas for a while. All we know is that it was for work. Then the fateful day arrived. It was 08-FEB-1935. Lewter came by the Everts house and asked to borrow Charles’ shotgun to do some hunting. Julia said that he needed to ask Charles, who was out clearing some trees. Lewter took the gun anyway and turned it on Julia and then one of the daughters. The other daughter ran from the house in the direction of her father. She was shot in the back. Lewter then went back in the house to finish Julia who was trying to crawl away. He nearly blew her arm off. After that he went to find Charles and gunned him down. Julia survived both attacks before succumbing 5 hours later in the hospital. There was no police force in the area so Lewter went to the Justice of the Peace to turn himself in. When police did arrive Lewter begged them to put him in the electric chair and get it over with. When asked why he had murdered them all he just kept saying, “Those folks weren’t living right.” This from a man who married a 14 year old girl. At one point he took off his glasses, broke the lenses, and tried to slit his wrists with a broken shard. He was placed under suicide watch at the state hospital. Details get fuzzy at this point. Ellen came back to AR. Lewter was convicted and sent to Arkansas State Penitentiary. Lena divorced him in 1936 and remarried the same day. She had 2 more children. Lewter was released at some point prior to his death and returned home. He was diagnosed with atherosclerotic brain syndrome and sent to the local VA hospital. He died in 1964. His daughter Mary Alice applied for a veteran’s grave marker for him and he is buried in Hot Springs AR. Mary Alice died in the early 2000’s. The Everts family that Lewter murdered is buried in a cemetery just north of Hot Springs. They’re all together in one site with one marker listing them all. Ellen lived until 2007. She’s buried near her family. We didn’t know any of this about Ellen until we were adults. It was our cousin, Minta, who gave us the broad details originally while we were recording an oral history of the family. When we asked Ellen about it she pulled out her box of clippings and told us the story. I wish we had known her better. In an effort to protect her the adults in our family kept us from knowing this woman the way she deserved. All of this is from oral history, corroborated by newspaper articles and other written materials. BTW this is not the story about the gruesome murder. Stay tuned.